Honestly never got that feeling from Maya. She does solo stuff with MC at least several times I can think of (memorably dancing and in the classroom at the Dorm Party), and it didn't feel like you were her second choice in those circumstances. Not to mention she reached out and helps the MC when she really doesn't need to by offering to let him stay in her dorm.Which is when she can't find Josy, that's what I don't like in the rleationship, while Josy at least properly comes looking for the MC, Maya doesn't.
Makes sense being her the "actual" lesbian, but still... petty me is petty me![]()
Early on she definitely felt more hesitant, but as you mentioned she's mostly attracted to the same sex and has known MC for only a few days or at most 1-2 weeks, whereas Josy had already known MC for 2 months by the time we see her in-game.